Pleasantly surprised this actually works very well for me! I’ve been struggling with natural deodorants , and the one I really liked is a bit too expensive for me at the moment. So this is awesome. Very happy.

This deodorant is the best. Even after I shower, I always felt the BO smell never went away. This really works for smell. It does leave a white residue. I wipe away the excess with my hand so it doesn’t transfer to my clothes. It a bit of a tacky feel. However, getting rid of the BO is worth any little inconvenience this product brings.

Best deodorant ever. Even if you sweat, if you are using this, you won't stink. Amazing! It can cause a white residue on the armpit area of your clothes, but it washes right out.

Shwally is a popular brand that offers a zinc and charcoal deodorant option, and it's definitely worth checking out. This deodorant is made from a blend of natural ingredients, including zinc oxide, activated charcoal, arrowroot powder, and coconut oil, among others.

One of the things that sets Shwally's zinc and charcoal deodorant apart from other options is the pleasant, subtle scent. Unlike some natural deodorants that can be overpowering or too earthy, this deodorant has a light, fresh scent that's perfect for everyday wear.

In terms of effectiveness, Shwally's zinc and charcoal deodorant does an excellent job of keeping odor at bay and absorbing moisture. It goes on smoothly and doesn't leave any residue, and it lasts all day without the need for reapplication.

Another great thing about this deodorant is that it's free from harmful chemicals, such as aluminum, parabens, and phthalates. It's also cruelty-free and vegan, which makes it a great choice for anyone looking for a more ethical and sustainable deodorant option.

Overall, Shwally's zinc and charcoal deodorant is a top-notch product that's definitely worth trying. It smells great, works well, and is made from natural and eco-friendly ingredients. If you're in the market for a new deodorant, this one is definitely worth considering.

It is truly unscented and feels nice on the skin. Above average odor protection for a natural deodorant. It is the best I have used so far in managing postpartum BO.

The price is a little high (I thought 2 came in one order.)

The Reality Check: I am one of those people who must wear deodorant. If I don't, I will start smelling within an hour of showering, even if I am just sitting on the couch. I spent months testing 9 aluminum-free brands in a professional office setting with 10k steps a day to find out which ones actually hold up and which ones are just a greasy mess.

The Heavy Hitters (Top Tier)

• Shwally Zinc and Charcoal: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance: The absolute gold standard for odor. This is the only one that gave me 24+ hours of protection.

Experience: Since it is tallow-based, it feels grease-heavy when you first apply it, but it dries up shortly after. Even though it contains a form of baking soda, I had zero irritation.

• The People’s Pharmacy MOM (Milk of Magnesia) Roll-on: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance: 12+ hours of solid protection with zero irritation.

Experience: This was a huge surprise. It is completely non-greasy and dries quickly, leaving a subtle white dry residue (like baby powder) that feels very clean. The fragrance-free version is great, and the scented one is subtle.

The Catch: Not widely available; you usually have to buy directly from their site, so shipping and handling fees will add to the cost.

High Performance (4 Stars)

• Salt and Stone (Bergamot and Hinoki): ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance: 12+ hours. The scent is the best of all products tested, but it is not subtle; it is strong and it will cling to your clothes all day.

Experience: Very effective, but the grease feeling is real and the baking soda eventually caused significant redness for me. Excellent customer service though; they sent a sensitive version for free.

• Gymati Fitness Spray: ⭐⭐⭐⭐

Performance: 8+ hours of protection.

Experience: A sporty scent that replaces the need for cologne. It is a quick-dry spray with no grease or stains.

The Catch: Because it is a spray, it has the tallest container of the bunch. It takes up more space in a gym bag or desk drawer.

The Middle Ground

• Kokoa Botanics: ⭐⭐⭐

Performance: 8+ hours.

Experience: This was the only plastic-free container I tested. However, it is very temperature dependent; if it is not warm enough, it crumbles in your armpit. The sweet scent transfers to your shirt and intensifies the longer you wear it.

The Catch: Not widely available besides directly from their website, so shipping and handling will add to the cost.

• Salt and Stone (Sensitive): ⭐⭐⭐

Performance: 6+ hours.

Experience: Solved the irritation but the protection dropped. It feels grease-heavy on application and does not dry fast enough before putting a shirt on. Scent is more subtle than the original formula.

The Low-Protection Group

• Clearly FRESH Magnesium Roll-On: ⭐⭐

Experience: Initial protection decreases quickly through time. After 6 hours, it is like not having any deodorant on at all. It is not greasy and dries quickly, but it just doesn't last.

• Kopari and Crystal Magnesium: ⭐⭐

Experience: Both smelled nice but were very greasy. They transferred all over my shirts and only lasted about 6 hours before the odor broke through.

Final Verdict for the High-Odor Individual:

1. Best Overall Protection: Shwally (for the 24hr protection)

2. Best Scent: Salt and Stone (Original)

3. Best Budget and Feel: People's Pharmacy MOM (for the dry, baby-powder finish)

4. Best Spray: Gymati (if you have the extra room in your bag)

Every other deodorant that i bought from the supermarket and drugstore would underperform. My armpits would start to smell just a couple hours after i showered and applied the deodorant (old spice, speedstick, degree, arm & hammer, etc.). This Shwally Zinc deodorant worked on the first day! Showered in the morning, applied shwally, and i had ZERO armpit smell at the end of the day... or the next morning! My guess is that the magic ingredient is the Zinc, but i really don't care - Shwally is my new deodorant, and will remain so for the foreseeable future! Thank you!

In perimenopause and searching for a natural deodorant that ACTUALLY worked for a long period of time seemed near impossible UNTIL I found Shwally!! THANK YOU!!!! This is absolutely worth the purchase , it works amazing , worth every penny and a little goes a long way!

Works great. First natural deodorant that I’ve found that actually works. I’m a very heavy sweater. Some days I work so much I don’t feel like taking a shower. I know I’m gross. But this stuff has lasted me two days without odor.

This deodorant is great. It lasts all day for me and smells good. I love that it’s natural. I give it four stars because it is expensive. I find myself repurchasing it often. After using it for a bit, it leaves a darkness on the skin underarms.

Was looking for a clean deoderant that was easily accessible (easily ordered on amazon). There's no such thing as the "perfect" clean deoderant HOWEVER this comes amazingly close.

I have realistic expectations; when atrocious chemicals are not involved, I know the product is likely to wear off at some point and require a 2nd application, and will not be a 100% smell blocker, which I am OK with. This deoderant goes on well. I wipe it under both pits in a circular motion and then rub it around a bit with my fingers. It does not require warming up or constant swipes-yay! Hopefully that stands as it starts getting colder here but if not, it's not really a concern of mine..product quality over ease of application any day! No skin irritation and I hardly need to apply a 2nd time in a single day. 10/10 would reccomend. Will be trying Shwally's other products!

I’ve been looking for a natural deodorant that actually works. I’ve tried a few different ones but this is the first to work. It protects all day to keep odor down.

You aren’t going to get a strong floral smell with organic/ natural deodorants. So if this is what you are looking for it will take time to get used to. I however really like the smell.

With real ingredients you don’t have to worry about irritation of skin and no worrying about absorption of horrible ingredients next to your lymph nodes.

By far the best natural deodorant I've ever bought. Lasts all day unlike most natural products.

Smells good initially but not compatible with my body, sadly.

I liked that there was no smell. I have issues with smells. The deodorant is smooth and not too sticky. I didn’t have irritation unless I had freshly shaved underarms. The product comes out quickly and goes fast. I have used other deodorants that last a full 24 hours. This doesn’t last as long as that. I can wear it all day and still be non-stinky but in the morning, it has stopped working.